Cheeseburgers hold a special place in the world of drive-thrus. But which fast food chain truly makes the best one?
We tried the burgers from the top 12 most fastfood burgers in America and ranked them from worst to best:
12. Checkers/Rally’s – Cheese Champ
Upon unwrapping the Checkers/Rally’s Cheese Champ, you might initially be impressed by its thickness and weight… until you realize that there’s essentially a small salad consisting mostly of shredded lettuce and onions on top of the patty.
If you were to flip the burger upside down and remove the bottom bun, it could easily pass as a salad with a beef disk on top. Furthermore, the patty itself is too thin and lacks the necessary char to stand up against the overpowering vegetables. This cheeseburger falls far short of its “Champ” title.
11. Burger King – The Whopper
The Whopper, Burger King’s iconic flagship burger, has long been hailed as a fast food classic. However, recent experiences suggest that this once-revered behemoth has lost its former glory. The Whopper’s downfall is a lamentable tale of wilted lettuce, lackluster tomatoes, and a flame-charred patty that overwhelms the other flavors, including the raw onions. The dryness of the patty only exacerbates the issue, causing the stale-tasting bun to crumble disappointingly. It seems that Burger King’s attention has shifted towards newer offerings like the Impossible Whopper and the Ch’King chicken sandwich, leaving the original Whopper to languish in the realm of gas station burgers.
10. Del Taco – The Double Del Cheeseburger
Del Taco’s Double Del Cheeseburger may not be the main attraction at this beloved fast food joint, but it deserves a moment in the spotlight. While it may be smaller in size compared to other offerings, this burger shouldn’t be dismissed as inconsequential. Its California-inspired tradition shines through with its signature Thousand Island-ish spread, which adds a tangy twist to the mayo-based dressing. The double medium-thick patties, though slightly lacking in flavor, compensate with their juicy tenderness. Topped with double cheese, lettuce (shredded taco-style), tomato slices, and diced onions, this burger offers a satisfying medley of textures and flavors.
9. White Castle – Cheese Slider
When it comes to sticking to its roots, the White Castle Cheese Slider takes the cake. This iconic burger is a simple yet satisfying combination of flavors and textures that has stood the test of time. With its tiny square patty punched with holes and steamed with onions, it may not sound like much, but it delivers exactly what you expect—a no-frills, no-bullshit burger experience.
Whether you enjoy them straight from the case or pick them up at the grocery store, White Castle burgers remain consistent. They are a go-to option, especially during late-night cravings or when you’re in the mood for a nostalgic fast food fix. While they may not be the most gourmet or trendy choice, there’s something comforting about their familiarity and reliability.
8. Jack in the Box – The Jumbo Jack
Jack in the Box is known for its creative and indulgent offerings, from stoner-friendly mashups to mega-stack chicken sandwiches. However, their signature Jumbo Jack takes a more straightforward approach, and that’s precisely why it works. In a menu that caters to adventurous taste buds, the Jumbo Jack provides a comforting and familiar option.
The Jumbo Jack features thick patty, tomato slices, American cheese, pickles, lettuce and diced onions. It all comes together on a split-top bun swiped with mayo. While it may not be the most memorable burger on the menu, its simplicity and balance make it a solid choice. It’s a reliable go-to when you want a classic, no-nonsense burger experience from Jack in the Box.
7. Carl’s Jr. & Hardee’s – Super Star with Cheese
Carl’s Jr. and Hardee’s have built a reputation for their hearty and indulgent burgers, often catering to the cravings of grill-loving dads. The Super Star with Cheese embodies this spirit, providing a satisfying and well-crafted burger experience.
With 2 patties that have been charbroiled, American cheese (2 slices), thick tomato slices, onions, lettuce, mayo and special sauce, the Super Star with Cheese is stacked with flavor. The grocery store-fresh toppings and charmingly misshapen, juicy patties create a burger that stands out.
6. Wendy’s – Dave’s Double
Wendy’s has mastered the art of the classic double cheeseburger with their iconic Dave’s Double. This burger features two juicy square patties, weighing in at 1/4lb each, cooked to perfection. Wendy’s takes pride in not cutting corners, and it shows in the quality and flavor of their burgers.
What sets Dave’s Double apart is the thoughtful balance of ingredients. The toppings, including tomato, leaf lettuce, onion slices, mayo, and ketchup, are generous but never overpower the star of the show—the beef. Wendy’s commitment to using fresh, never frozen meat adds to the burger’s exceptional taste and juiciness. The patties are well-seasoned, with just the right amount of salt, and they deliver a satisfying chew with every bite.
While the Dave’s Double is a standout, even the single patty version holds its own. The burger stands out amidst the crowded fast food landscape, reminding us of the simple pleasures of a well-executed classic. Wendy’s commitment to quality and their ability to let the beef shine make the Dave’s Double a top contender in the fast food burger realm.
5. McDonald’s – Quarter Pounder with Cheese
McDonald’s may not have reinvented the wheel with their Quarter Pounder with Cheese, but they did breathe new life into this classic burger. By switching to fresh, non-frozen meat, McDonald’s elevated the flavor and overall experience of their Quarter Pounder, making it a star on their menu once again.
What sets the Quarter Pounder apart is the improved beefy flavor of the patty. The juiciness, saltiness, and the occasional burst of burnt drippings create a delightful savory experience. The toppings, including the crispy onions and tangy pickles, add layers of texture and taste. McDonald’s managed to enhance a beloved classic while maintaining its familiarity and nostalgic appeal.
4. Whataburger – Double Meat Whataburger
In the heart of Texas, Whataburger reigns supreme, and their Double Meat Whataburger is a true icon. This Texas-sized burger features two thin grilled patties, measuring a whopping five inches each, sandwiched between a plain bun. Toppings include tomato, lettuce, pickles, diced onions, and a smear of Whataburger’s proprietary mustard.
The Double Meat Whataburger is a testament to everything that makes Texas proud. The patties are thin yet wide, providing a solid base for the generous amount of fresh toppings. The mustard adds a tangy kick that cuts through the richness of the beef, while melted cheese brings it all together. The burger is a flavor explosion that showcases the best of Texan burger craftsmanship.
Whataburger’s Double Meat Whataburger may seem intimidating in size, but every bite is a delightful combination of textures and flavors. The freshness of the toppings, the savory meat, and the balanced mustard create a memorable eating experience. It’s no wonder that Whataburger holds a special place in the hearts of Texans and burger enthusiasts alike.
3. Sonic Drive-In – SuperSonic Double Cheeseburger
The first noticeable difference is the burger’s beefy flavor, which shines through with each bite. The inclusion of ketchup and mayo as default condiments adds a pleasant acidity that enhances the overall taste. Even the lettuce tastes fresher, and the tomato slices burst with more vibrant flavors. Additionally, Sonic addressed a previous gripe by providing a structurally sound bun that holds up throughout the meal.
Sonic’s SuperSonic Double Cheeseburger has become one of the best fast food cheeseburgers available today. The combination of improved ingredients, the juicy patties bound together by slices of American cheese, and the well-balanced toppings make for a satisfying and enjoyable burger experience. Sonic’s efforts to elevate their burgers have not gone unnoticed, and this burger is a shining example of their commitment to quality.
2. In-N-Out Burger – Double-Double
In-N-Out Burger’s Double-Double is a legendary fast food burger that embodies the essence of a classic hamburger. This West Coast favorite has earned its spot as one of the top fast food burgers money can buy. While you can customize your order with the not-so-secret menu, the Double-Double is outstanding even without any modifications.
The secret to In-N-Out’s success lies in the use of fresh, never frozen beef patties that are ground in their own facilities. This results in exceptionally juicy patties that pair perfectly with melty American cheese. The toppings, including iceberg lettuce, raw onions, plump tomatoes, and their special “animal sauce” all come together harmoniously. The spongy bun adds a comforting texture to complete the experience.
In-N-Out’s Double-Double is an affordable and accessible burger that showcases the best of California’s burger culture. The quality of the ingredients, the attention to detail, and the dedication to freshness make it a must-try for anyone visiting the West Coast. It’s a burger that truly captures the essence of what a hamburger should be.
1. Culver’s – Double ButterBurger with Cheese
At the top of the list, we have the crowned champion: Culver’s Double ButterBurger with Cheese. Hailing from Wisconsin, this burger is a true delight for the senses. It features two fresh-grilled patties made by hand, topped with American cheese from Wisconsin, red onions, tomatoes and pickles, all nestled in a fluffy bun that has been grilled and dabbed with butter.
The Double ButterBurger lives up to its name, with the lightly toasted bun enveloping the flavorsome beef and accompanying toppings. The patties are thin but juicy, perfectly complemented by the slight crunch of the toasted bun and the freshness of the shredded lettuce. What sets this burger apart is the outstanding quality of every ingredient. From the Wisconsin-made cheese to the vibrant vegetables, Culver’s ensures that each element is of the highest standard.
Culver’s Double ButterBurger with Cheese transcends the fast food label. It feels like a burger crafted with care and attention, reminiscent of a mom n’ pop shop. The flavor profile is elevated, and every bite is a symphony of taste and texture. Paired with a side of cheese curds and a frozen custard, this burger truly embodies the pinnacle of fast food burger excellence. Culver’s is a Midwest treasure, and we hope that the rest of the nation gets to experience the joy of a ButterBurger soon.